February 6, 2011 | Atlanta Journal-Constitution, The (GA)
Author/Byline: John AdamsFor the AJC | Page: F1 | Section: ajchomes
453 Words | Readability: Lexile: 1070, grade level(s): 7 8 9

My column last week on estimating property values brought a flurry of questions. Here are the best:
Q: You said appraisers use three approaches to value, but that only one was meaningful for us. Why is that?
A: The “comparable sale” method is considered most indicative of typical buyer behavior in owner-occupied residential real estate. The other two methods are the replacement method, which is most often used in unique properties like church sanctuaries, and the income approach, most often used to evaluate rental properties, both residential and commercial.
Assessors must now consider the income approach when assessing income properties, which may help lower tax bills for many owners of rental properties.
Q: You said we need three comparable homes that have sold recently nearby. What does “nearby” mean?
A: In an ideal world, the comparable sales would be adjacent to your home. Preferably, they would be within a few blocks and in the same subdivision. So long as they are comparable in other amenities and features, we can include home sales up to a mile away from yours.
Q: What does “similar” mean?
A: The more similar a recently sold home is to yours, the more relevant it is to your home’s value. Everything matters, but the most important are location, age and style of construction, bedroom and bath count, and heated and cooled finished square footage.
Q: You talked about contacting a couple of real estate professionals and asking them to help you gather data about recently sold homes. Isn’t that taking advantage of the agents? Shouldn’t they be paid?
A: Real estate professionals use a variety of methods to meet and establish rapport with prospective home sellers and buyers. One common method is to offer homeowners a free “competitive market analysis” listing all recent sales and comparing them to the home of the owner.
Because your home’s value is such an important topic, the so-called “CMA” is an excellent way of meeting owners and getting a private tour with them in their homes.
In contrast, a licensed appraiser can hope for no future relationship with the homeowner, and performs a professional service and expects to be paid. Remember that the agent is, in fact, doing you a favor. But I recommend you be honest with them and tell them you are asking for their help in order to protest your tax assessment. You are likely to get better results.
Q: You recommended taking digital photos of all recent sales in your neighborhood. Why?
A: A picture will help you support your claim that a sale is, in fact, a comparable sale.
JohnAdams is a broker and investor. He answers real estate questions on radio station WGKA (920am) every Saturday at noon. For more real estate information or to make a comment, visit www.money99.com.
